Shiphero Blog

Top 6 Best Order Fulfillment Options for Square

In this article
The end of seller shipping
The Solution: Integrated TikTok Shop logistics
Critical action for Shopify users
Join us before the deadline and save

If you’re a small or medium business owner that takes credit card payments online, you’ve probably heard of Square even if it’s not your preferred payment platform. They’ve been all over the news as a success story of a company that grew from a niche manufacturer of payment processing hardware for small merchants into a $100-billion-plus financial ecosystem.And if you’re a client of Square Online or thinking about becoming one, then you know you need a strong, reliable fulfillment partner to complement the ease of use Square Online offers. Because if only two of the three elements of your customers’ experience with you are operating at peak efficiency (shopping and paying), and the third (fulfillment) is lacking, you’re playing with fire:

  • 45% of shoppers expect their items to be delivered within four to five days
  • 69% of online shoppers say they will be significantly less likely to shop with a retailer if they do not deliver within two days of the promised date
  • 16% of online shoppers will take their business elsewhere after one incorrect delivery date

Before getting into the best fulfillment options for Square Online users, below is a quick recap for new eCommerce entrepreneurs. If you’re a veteran in the eCommerce space, skip down to “How We Choose the Best Square Fulfillment Companies.”

What is Square?

Square is a mobile payment processing app and card reader, and the very first of its kind, which is why the adoption rate was so high.Overnight, Square (and then Square Online) let anyone accept credit card payments with their phones or tablets. And that “anyone” included those who up until that point only knew their business as a cash business like farmers’ market and flea market vendors.Square was also unique when it launched because it didn’t require contracts, commitments, applications or monthly fees. All you needed was an email address and knowledge of how the Square dashboard works.Today, Square Online is a complete revenue collection system for vendors on and offline; every account holder is enabled to accept online orders, ring up orders at POS and receive payments through the Square dashboard.

What is Order Fulfillment?

Order fulfillment is a quick way to describe the process of receiving a purchase order from a customer, processing that order and getting the purchased product to the purchaser. The fulfillment process begins when a customer’s order is received and ends when that customer receives their order.When the customer receives the item or items they ordered in the time they were promised, this is considered positive fulfillment. If a hiccup anywhere along the fulfillment chain disrupts the process and the customer either receives their package late or doesn’t get what they asked for, this is considered negative fulfillment.

How Does the Square Fulfillment Process Work?

Square (and Square Online) makes fulfillment extremely easy for anyone from the Square dashboard.From your Square dashboard that you can integrate into your site, you can set up curbside pickup or shipping fulfillment for any item. And you can set up a shipping fee if you see fit. Alternatively, you can use Square Online to build your own eCommerce site with a fulfillment option.Either way, once you’re ready to accept orders with Square Online, you can choose your fulfillment method form the Square dashboard: fulfill yourself (i.e., you find the item, wrap it, box it and add arrange for curbside pickup or prepare the shipping label, ship it and track the shipment to make sure it gets to your customer), or you can bring in a third-party logistics (3PL) company for fulfillment.

What Does a 3PL Order Fulfillment Provider Do?

A 3PL order fulfillment provider will set the fulfillment method and handle the entire fulfillment process. It’s a massive headache off your plate and it gives you back hours of time per week (or more depending on how much you sell and how many shipping labels you have to produce) to put towards growing your business.Some 3PLs will be software to help you pick, pack, create shipping labels and ship items purchased by your customers. Others own and operate their own warehouses to store your products and ship from there. And a few (like ShipHero) offer both.

What Are the Benefits of Using an eCommerce Order Fulfillment Service?

As mentioned above, the big benefit of using a 3PL for eCommerce fulfillment is getting rid of a huge pain in the neck, which you can do right from the Square dashboard.The fulfillment process has so many moving parts and so much that can go wrong along the way that entire college-level courses are dedicated to it. And if you run an eCommerce business, you’re most likely too busy to take it. This would put you in a disadvantageous position if things went off the rails.With a 3PL behind the scenes, whatever happens wouldn’t be your problem. And if the worst did happen, you’d know you had real experts in the field to respond, react and fix the issue before it cost you a customer.Find out more about ShipHero’s fully-outsourced Fulfillment Solution now.

Factors to Consider While Selecting an Order Fulfillment Partner for Square Online

Like in almost every other business-to-business service market, the 3PL options for fulfillment are plentiful and varied, with many pretenders for every one contender. That’s why it’s important to be diligent in your research before selecting a 3PL fulfillment partner for your eCommerce business.

Fulfillment Type/Order Fulfillment Speed

This is the biggest one because failure here can lead directly to lost business (as stated above). You should definitely be looking for a 3PL that offers some sort of same-day delivery, as 41 percent of consumers are willing to pay a charge for same-day delivery.

Pricing and Storage/Fulfillment/Transaction Fees

On the surface, you’ll pay more for 3PL fulfillment than if you were to do it yourself. But if time is money, the investment in self-fulfillment is substantial. So, the goal when finding a 3PL is to spend less than you’d spend doing it yourself. Only you know that number, but be steadfast getting under it.

Returns Management

Less than one in 10 products bought in bricks-and-mortar stores are returned. Online, it’s close to 30 percent. So, the effectiveness of your returns process is very important for operations, but also for customer retention: 92 percent of consumers surveyed said they would buy again if the product return process was easy.

What to Look for in a Square Online Fulfillment Partner

Once you’ve narrowed down your list of possible 3PL vendors, you’d be wise to look under the hoods of each to make sure they can work with Square Online and the Square dashboard, and that they are in fact a fulfillment expert for Square Online. How well they execute the fulfillment type they promise will dictate their value to you.

eCommerce Platform Integration

This is obviously the most important part. If a 3PL provider can’t plug into Square Online or the Square dashboard, they’re of no use to you whatsoever.

Multichannel Integration

You never want your 3PL to keep you from growing, so you have to trust them to know everything about where you want to start selling next, and how to follow or adjust their fulfillment type to handle those orders.

Ease of Use

Often overlooked in 3PL selection is smoothness across the fulfillment process, and this starts with an interface that everyone along the line can use. And be picky. Find something you know will work for you and your team, where the transaction fees are minimal or non-existent, and that works with the Square dashboard.

How We Chose the Best Square Online Fulfillment Companies

You have many order fulfillment partner choices, so choosing one can be tough. Fortunately, we can help with that. Here are the criteria we use when choosing the best Square fulfillment companies:

  • Shipping speed
  • Fulfillment network
  • Fulfillment software features
  • Returns management
  • Subscription, storage and shipping costs

The Best Square Online Fulfillment Companies

1. ShipHero

ShipHero was founded by a former eCommerce entrepreneur who was frustrated with the shipping software options available and decided to do something about it.

Pros

As mentioned above, the big pro ShipHero has going for it is the choice you have to either use their software to ship from your warehouse, or to let them ship your items from their warehouse, giving you back days of time by the end of every year.

Cons

Right now, the perceived knock on ShipHero is that it’s not a market leader yet. But that’s changing quickly.

Pricing

ShipHero Fulfillment offers flat rate shipping costs that includes picking, packing, shipping, mailing supplies and postage. Pricing is more competitive without shipping zones and costs are more predictable.Find out more about ShipHero’s fully-outsourced Fulfillment Solution now.

2. ShipStation

ShipStation is a web-based order management and shipping software. They don’t have their own warehouses, but their software is used in North America, Europe and Australia.

Pros

  • Fairly flexible and relatively easy to use
  • Integrates with QuickBooks

Cons

  • Can be clunky to use for some people
  • Once your shipments reach 500 per day or more, the system loses its efficiency and can actually slow you down

Pricing

They offer six tiers up to $229.99/month based on how much you think you’re going to ship.

3. ShipBob

ShipBob is another web-based platform in the ShipStation family, and it has a built-in analytics cruncher.

Pros

  • The ShipBob staff is very large, so help with problems when they arise is easy to get

Cons

  • The learning curve is steep for beginners and tech newbies
  • Struggle with API issues and compatibility

Pricing

Shipping costs are customized per client.

4. Ordoro

A shipping solution for small- to medium-sized businesses with a small business, homespun feel.

Pros

It has an intricate inventory tracking tool, which works well for eCommerce companies with multiple SKUs.

Cons

Overall, the features aren’t as robust as others.

Pricing

Pricing is definitely competitive, but you get what you pay for.

5. Shipedge

Shipedge has a suite of products to manage the entire order management lifecycle, supply chain and logistics in one centralized platform.

Pros

Easy to integrate with most platforms.

Cons

Not the most user-friendly interface.

Pricing

Pricing is modular.Find out more about ShipHero’s fully-outsourced Fulfillment Solution now.

6. Printful

Printful is a 3PL fulfillment company primarily for eCommerce apparel companies, and specifically apparel creators.

Pros

You can use Printful to design your own products

Cons

  • Its functionality is limited to the needs of its primary audience
  • Products are not made until ordered which could cause shipping delays

Pricing

Pricing is customized

Final Thoughts About Square Fulfillment

If you’re a Square Online customer, you clearly care about quality and about giving your customers the best possible experience. By choosing the right 3PL shipping partner, you complete the loop.

Don’t work with Square? Find the best carriers for many of the highest profile marketplaces on the web.

Top 10 Best Order Fulfillment for AmazonTop 10 Best Order Fulfillment Partners for WalmartTop 10 Order Fulfillment for eBayTop 10 Best Order Fulfillment Options for WixTop 10 Best Order Fulfillment Partners for ChannelAdvisorTop 6 Best Order Fulfillment Partners for WooCommerceTop 10 Best Order Fulfillment Options for BigCommerceTop 10 Best Order Fulfillment Options for SquarespaceTop 10 Best Order Fulfillment Options for eCommerce Sellers

the process

Explore more of our features

No items found.
Shiphero logo on a grey backgroundWarehouse worker wearing a yellow safety vest and gloves, writing on a clipboard with boxes in the background.
April 7, 2026

5 Top Hurdles Our Prospects Face Before Signing With ShipHero

Executive Summary

Transitioning to a new Warehouse Management System (WMS) is a high-stakes decision that often triggers concerns regarding downtime, data integrity, and workforce adaptation. As warehouses prepare for 2026 growth, understanding these common hurdles—and the technical solutions that resolve them—is essential for a successful migration. This guide addresses the five primary barriers to adoption and how a high-velocity infrastructure ensures a seamless transition.

The Challenge: Overcoming Transition Anxiety

Warehouse operators frequently hesitate to upgrade due to perceived risks that can halt operations. These challenges typically include:

  • The Switching Cost Fear: Anxiety that implementation costs and downtime will outweigh long-term ROI.
  • Legacy Workflow Dependency: A heavy reliance on desktop-heavy, traditional Purchase Order (PO) workflows.
  • Workforce Skepticism: Concern that floor staff will struggle with new hardware or complex interfaces.

The Solution: A Framework for Seamless Migration

To clear these hurdles, a structured implementation strategy is used to prioritize data density and entity clarity.

  • Staged Migration: A phased approach that optimizes inbound logic and mobile setup first, ensuring current orders remain active while layering in advanced features.
  • Mobile-First Inbound: A shift from desktop-heavy POs to mobile architecture, allowing inventory to become sellable minutes after hitting the dock.
  • Workforce Hero: An authentication tool using PIN-based access or scan-to-login badges that makes staff productive within their first hour.
  • Precise Inventory Control: Utilizing high-concurrency architecture to ensure every pick on the floor reflects in Shopify or other sales channels in real-time.
  • Total Real-Time Control: A dashboard that provides visibility into picker productivity, replenishment status, and the Hospital error-handling queue.

Why This Matters for 3PLs and Brands

In the competitive eCommerce landscape, staying stagnant with manual workarounds is often more costly than the transition itself. Moving to a high-velocity WMS converts your warehouse from a cost center into a growth engine by providing Labor Efficiency and ROI through automated routing and reduced authentication friction.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take for staff to become productive on the new system?

Because the platform is built for the floor worker, features like Workforce Hero allow seasonal temps and new staff to be authenticated and productive in under an hour.

Will I lose visibility of my warehouse floor during automation?

No. High-velocity infrastructure increases visibility by providing Total Real-Time Control. Managers can monitor exactly what is in the Hospital queue and track replenishment in real-time from a single dashboard.

What happens to inventory accuracy during migration?

Before going live, a ground-up audit is performed using cycle counting tools. The system's architecture ensures that every movement on the floor is synchronized with sales channels instantly, maintaining 99.9% accuracy.

Read more
Arrow icon
Shiphero logo on a grey backgroundStack of blue plastic storage bins next to a glowing Tap-to-Pack  device and a tablet with a red ShipHero logo on a warehouse table.
March 2, 2026

Meet Tap-to-Pack: Eliminate Packing Errors and Speed Up Your Pack Line

Picture a packer at Peak Season. A box is in front of them, a product in each hand, and somewhere on a cluttered desk there's a mouse they need to find to confirm the order. They look down. They hunt. They click. Then they do it again. Thousands of times a day.

That moment of friction is small. But it is never just one moment. Multiply it across your entire pack line, across an entire shift, and you are looking at a measurable and largely invisible drag on your total throughput.

What Is Tap-to-Pack?

Tap-to-Pack is a purpose-built hardware controller designed by ShipHero to eliminate digital friction at the packing station. It connects via USB-C, requires no drivers or additional software, and syncs automatically with the ShipHero WMS packing app. This new system is now available at the ShipHero Store.

Instead of navigating a screen with a keyboard and mouse, packers execute every high-frequency command — such as selecting box sizes, printing labels, finalizing orders, flagging exceptions — with a single physical tap on one of eight programmable buttons.

Key specifications:

  • Connects via USB-C, plug-and-play
  • 8 programmable buttons on the Main Hub, expandable to 24
  • Integrated LED strips for visual confirmation (green = success, red = error)
  • High-fidelity audio cues to support eyes-on-product workflows
  • Industrial-grade, rugged build for warehouse environments
  • Compatible with the ShipHero WMS packing app (v1.0 or higher required for Tap-to-Pack devices)

Why Keyboards and Mice Fail in Warehouses

Most warehouses are running 2026 operations on 1990s peripheral standards. The keyboard and mouse were designed for spreadsheets and emails, not high-volume fulfillment. When used at a packing station, they create three compounding problems:

  1. Divided attention. Packers must split focus between the physical product in their hands and a digital UI on a screen. This is what we call screen-stare fatigue. That is: a constant, low-level attention split that accumulates across every single order.
  2. Flow state interruptions. When a packer has to hunt for a cursor or navigate a multi-step UI, they lose their rhythm. At scale, those micro-interruptions translate into a significant reduction in orders packed per hour.
  3. Input errors. The further a packer's attention drifts from the product, the higher the risk that a wrong item ships. A mispack costs you twice:  once to resolve it, and once in the customer relationship it damages.

The problem is not your people. It is the tools you are asking them to use.

How Tap-to-Pack Works

Tap-to-Pack introduces a "Rodent-Free" packing standard: a workflow where the packer's hands stay on the product, their eyes stay on the work, and the software fades into the background.

The device guides the packer through two feedback systems:

  • LED strips: A green pulse confirms a successful action. A red alert stops an error before the box is sealed.
  • Audio cues: High-fidelity sound signals reinforce every action without requiring the packer to look at a screen.

ShipHero customers running Tap-to-Pack are already seeing a 90% reduction in on-screen interactions and a significant increase in the number of orders packed per hour, without adding headcount or changing their warehouse layout.

Scaling Your Pack Line With Tap-to-Pack

One of the hardest challenges in fulfillment is absorbing volume quickly, especially during Peak Season, when temporary staff need to reach target productivity fast.

Because Tap-to-Pack's interface is physical and intuitive, there is almost nothing to teach. Pick up the product, follow the light, tap the button. New packers can reach target productivity in minutes rather than hours.

The system is also modular:

  • Start with 8 buttons on the Main Hub for core packing workflows
  • Expand to 16 or 24 buttons by connecting additional hubs as workflows grow in complexity
  • Configurable per station — buttons can be mapped to the actions most relevant to each packing role

Whether you are a growing DTC brand or a high-volume 3PL, Tap-to-Pack is designed so your hardware never becomes a ceiling on what your team can do.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is ShipHero Tap-to-Pack? 

Tap-to-Pack is a programmable, industrial-grade hardware controller that connects to the ShipHero WMS and allows warehouse packers to execute packing station commands, such as printing labels, selecting boxes, and completing orders. All with a single physical button press, eliminating the need for a keyboard and mouse.

How does Tap-to-Pack connect to the ShipHero WMS? 

The device connects via USB-C and syncs automatically with the ShipHero WMS packing app. It is a true plug-and-play solution: no drivers, no background software, and no manual configuration required.

Can I customize what each button does? 

Yes. Buttons are configurable for a range of packing actions, including Print Label, Complete Order, Select Box Size, and the Hospital function, which flags a problematic order and keeps the line moving without stopping to resolve it on screen.

What if I need more than 8 buttons? 

The system is fully modular. Connect up to two additional 8-button hubs to the Main Hub for a total of 24 programmable buttons, supporting even the most complex multi-step packing workflows.

What version of the ShipHero packing app is required? 

Tap-to-Pack devices require ShipHero Packing App v1.0 or higher. The current release is v1.1.0.

Read more
Arrow icon
Shiphero logo on a grey background
September 9, 2025

How AI is Transforming Warehouse Management: Impact, Benefits, and Use Cases

Imagine running a warehouse where orders are picked quickly, inventory is accurate, and all operations run smoothly without any errors or delays. Thanks to Artificial Intelligence, this can now become a reality with ease.

AI is transforming warehouse management by enhancing efficiency, intelligence, and the ability to meet the rapid demands of today’s eCommerce-driven market.

ShipHero is pioneering this revolution with its AI-powered warehouse solutions, setting new industry benchmarks. This article explores ShipHero’s AI Picking feature, highlighting how it’s transforming warehouse management and enhancing operational efficiency.

Benefits of AI in Warehouse Management

The integration of AI technologies, including machine learning, robotics, and predictive analytics, is revolutionizing warehouse operations, driving significant improvements in efficiency, accuracy, and overall performance. These innovations are optimizing processes across various areas, from inventory management to order fulfillment. Below are the key benefits of AI in warehouse management.

  • Improves efficiency: By automating routine tasks, AI speeds up warehouse operations and streamlines workflows.
  • Reduces operational costs: With AI automating repetitive tasks, businesses can save on labor costs and minimize errors.
  • Enhances inventory management: AI ensures that inventory is always accurate, with real-time updates and better control over stock levels.
  • Predicts demand: AI accurately predicts demand, enabling businesses to manage inventory effectively and avoid stockouts or excess stock.

Key Components of AI-Driven Warehouse Systems

A combination of AI technologies is shaping smarter warehouse systems to help revolutionize warehouse management.

  • Inventory Management Systems – AI-powered inventory management systems ensure that stock levels are continuously updated and accurately tracked to improve operational efficiency and minimize errors in inventory counts.
  • Automated Guided Vehicles (AGVs) – Automated vehicles (AGVs) optimize routing by quickly transporting goods, speeding up processing times, and improving throughput.
  • Robotic Process Automation (RPA) – RPA automates repetitive tasks like picking, sorting, and shipping to allow 24/7 warehouse operations with minimal human intervention.
  • Predictive Analytics and Demand Forecasting – AI tools predict demand accurately, ensuring optimal inventory levels and reducing stockouts or overstocking.

ShipHero’s AI Picking: A Game Changer in Warehouse Efficiency

ShipHero has taken AI integration to the next level with its AI Picking feature, designed to significantly improve warehouse efficiency. This feature automates the picking process, reducing the reliance on manual labor and enhancing productivity in ways that were once thought impossible.

Let’s dive deeper into how ShipHero’s AI Picking works and the advantages it offers.

How AI Picking Works

AI Picking optimizes warehouse operations in two key ways:

  • AI Path Optimization: By calculating the most efficient routes, walking time is reduced by up to 30%, allowing pickers to spend more time fulfilling orders.
  • Smart Batching: Orders are intelligently grouped to maximize pick density, minimizing trips while speeding up processing times.

Benefits of AI Picking

The AI Picking feature delivers a wide range of benefits:

    Increased Productivity: With optimized paths and smart batching, pickers can fulfill more orders in less time, dramatically increasing throughput.Lower Labor Costs: AI Picking reduces the need for human labor, cutting operational costs.Improved Warehouse Efficiency: Path optimization and smart batching maximize space and resources, streamlining operations.

Broader Impacts of AI in Warehouse Management

The transformative power of AI extends far beyond just picking. AI is also revolutionizing other aspects of warehouse management, driving improvements in operational efficiency, inventory management, and safety.

Operational Efficiency

AI automates tasks, reducing errors and increasing speed. Automated sorting and real-time inventory tracking ensure accuracy, while real-time monitoring helps managers adapt and ensure timely deliveries.

Inventory Management

AI plays a vital role in maintaining accurate inventory levels. By leveraging predictive analytics, AI can forecast demand and optimize stock levels, helping warehouses avoid both stockouts and overstock situations. This leads to better inventory management and fewer disruptions in supply chains.

Safety and Compliance

AI-driven systems can monitor warehouse conditions to ensure safety and compliance with industry regulations. These systems can analyze warehouse data and predict potential hazards before they occur, proactively reducing risks and ensuring a safer working environment.

Applications of AI in Supply Chain and Logistics

AI technologies are playing a transformative role in the supply chain and logistics sectors by improving efficiency, reducing costs, and enhancing decision-making.

These intelligent systems effortlessly manage supply chain processes by using data to optimize operations, predict trends, and automate routine tasks. This ultimately reshapes everything, from how goods are moved to stored and delivered.

  • Inventory Optimization: AI analyzes sales data, trends, and external factors to optimize stock levels. This reduces stockouts, overstocking, and excess inventory, ensuring more accurate and cost-effective inventory management.
  • Demand Forecasting: AI helps predict future demand by analyzing historical data and market conditions. This allows businesses to plan inventory, production, and procurement more efficiently, reducing waste and ensuring product availability.
  • Route Planning and Optimization: AI also optimizes delivery routes by considering real-time factors, including traffic and weather conditions. This helps businesses reduce fuel costs, improve delivery times, and enhance overall logistics efficiency.
  • Warehouse Automation: AI-powered robots can automate picking, sorting, and packing in warehouses. This increases accuracy, reduces labor costs, and enhances order fulfillment speed, eventually improving overall warehouse efficiency.

The Future of AI in Warehouse Management

The future of warehouse management looks promising with greater automation and efficiency, but future warehouse digitization brings challenges, such as high upfront costs and the need for skilled personnel.

Emerging Trends and Innovations

AI-powered drones, autonomous robots, and IoT integration are smart warehouse technologies that are revolutionizing warehouse operations. Drones will deliver goods quickly, while robots automate sorting and transportation, thereby reducing the need for manual labor.

IoT and AI integration will enable real-time monitoring and optimization of operations. Smart technology in warehouses is leading to fully automated systems that are faster, scalable, and need minimal human input.

Challenges and Considerations

While AI offers immense benefits, businesses must also consider certain challenges. High initial investments in AI technology, data security concerns, and the need for skilled personnel are just a few of the hurdles that must be addressed.

However, with a strategic approach, companies can eliminate the challenges and embrace AI’s full potential to boost accuracy in picking and improve overall warehouse operations.

Key Takeaways

  • AI is transforming warehouse management by making operations faster, more accurate, and cost-effective.
  • ShipHero’s AI Picking system demonstrates how AI can help warehouses handle more orders, cut down on labor costs, and streamline their processes.
  • AI improves routing, aids decision-making, and ensures timely stock replenishment, helping businesses stay competitive in eCommerce.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can AI help in reducing warehouse errors?

AI minimizes error by automating tasks like inventory tracking, order picking, and sorting, ensuring greater accuracy and efficiency.

Can AI be used for predictive analytics in warehouse management?

Yes, AI-driven predictive analytics can predict demand, track inventory levels, and improve supply chain efficiency by forecasting needs with greater accuracy to help businesses stay ahead of trends and market fluctuations.

Is AI in warehouse management affordable for small businesses?

AI solutions are becoming more cost-effective thanks to cloud-based services and subscription pricing models. These options make AI technology more accessible to small businesses, allowing them to take advantage of its benefits without large upfront costs.

Read more
Arrow icon